honestly, i was perfectly happy with the default setup of GE before it went down. Search bar and topic navigation on the right. Was easy to use and navigate. Info displayed on the rest of the page was well formatted, easy to read/understand/follow. Text was large enough to read easily, but small enough to fit all the info without crowding the page. I never had any complaints with it.
I wouldn't no for sure till i tried it i guess, but i think i would dislike a pop out menu. Reason being, when i switch windows over to GE its usually for one of two things. Either recheck info that is already up, in which case having the menu bar their or not doesn't matter to much. Or to search something different then what i have currently displayed. In which case i want the menu bar their and ready to go. Having the extra effort of opening and closing a pop up menu bar would just getting annoying i think.
Also (and this might seem trivial) since the majority of ppl are right handed, and using the mouse on the right side, it is easier to maneuver the on screen mouse on the right side. If your injured or tired or anything, and find yourself practically laying down in your chair, stretching that arm to barely reach the mouse, that little bit of room saved could make all the difference. (or maybe thats just me)
