Valefor.Prothescar said: »
99 Masamune > 99 Amano > 95 Masamune > 95 Amano > 90 Masamune >= 100 TP Bonus
90 Masa > 95 Amano
As for 99 Amano vs 99 Masa. ACC is less of a concern for SAM then other jobs. (60%+ Zanshin ACC bonus + excellent gear options) With that said there are definitely times where Amano will pull ahead, they are just a very small portion of the time. The 20str(15att) from Masa will always be of benefit.
SAM also over TPs and has JAs that all favor using Fudo/Shoha.
TPbonus is damn good for the time required to make one but the ODD,OD2.5 and damage of Relic/Emp is very potent even with SAMs high WS to melee split.