@Ina: A sorcerer and a philosopher aren't the same thing, and it's the one and only time I've ever seen the comparison. Philosophy has absolutely nothing to do with magic, but then I guess that does actually give credence to the change, since it's talking about a stone that belongs to a powerful wizard. The only problem with that is that a Philosopher's Stone is a real thing. Or at least, a not real thing with a very long history.
I think it was in "Old English" Sorcerers were also known as philosophers, could be wrong on that though
The first book in the Harry Potter series and the movie adaptation both have a different title in the United Kingdom. British author J.K. Rowling titled her first book Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, and her British publisher, Bloomsbury Publishing, retained that title. Scholastic later published the book in the U.S., changing the title to Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, and making other minor changes. When Warner Brothers -- an American company -- bought the movie rights, it kept the American book title.
The Harry Potter in Tayside site quotes Rowling's explanation:
Arthur Levine, my American editor, and I decided that words should be altered only where we felt they would be incomprehensible, even in context, to an American reader... The title change was Arthur's idea initially, because he felt that the British title gave a misleading idea of the subject matter. In England, we discussed several alternative titles and Sorcerer's Stone was my idea.
Other sources offer slightly different reasons for the title change. The Harry Potter Lexicon says, "Scholastic thought that a child wouldn't buy a book with the word 'philosopher' in the title." The U.K.-based Harry Potter Teaching Resources site suggests that the book was retitled "...presumably to make it sound more magic orientated rather than philosophy orientated!"
Perhaps Scholastic doubted that American grade-schoolers would be familiar with the mythic philosopher's stone, a mineral substance that could transform base metal into gold. Alchemists of the Middle Ages sought to discover the stone and attributed many great powers to it.
As a result of the name change, all the scenes in the movie that mention the stone were filmed twice -- once with actors saying "sorcerer's" and once with them saying "philosopher's." Maybe the alternate versions of those scenes will turn up on DVD someday soon.
Lame :/
didnt know about that, Philosopher Stone makes more sense
Imo, when I think sorcerer, my mind goes to Jafar from Aladdin. After he wishes to become a sorcerer comes to mind, (when he gets crazy magic powers) When I hear philosopher, I think of Aristotle.
As a kid, I would associate magic more with sorcerer than philosopher. Philosopher just makes me think of a thinker, or wise person.
I didn't realise that was even supposed to be Crabbe, I was wondering why there was some random black dude with him instead of Crabbe. WTF!
It's not supposed to be Crabbe, it's Blaise Zabini, another Slytherin student, he was in a few of the books, and the last 3 movies, but not in any major capacity. The actor that played Crabbe got in trouble for pot, and they killed Goyle off instead of him, and had a different Slytherin act as Draco's second stooge for the scene in the movie... God, I am a nerd. sorry. To contribute:
I didn't realise that was even supposed to be Crabbe, I was wondering why there was some random black dude with him instead of Crabbe. WTF!
The actor who plays Crabbe quit. So they put in Zabini who was seen in the half blood prince. Only if your one of those "I watch the movies and love them but won't read the books they are based off" morons would you truly laugh over this.
I didn't realise that was even supposed to be Crabbe, I was wondering why there was some random black dude with him instead of Crabbe. WTF!
The actor who plays Crabbe quit. So they put in Zabini who was seen in the half blood prince. Only if your one of those "I watch the movies and love them but won't read the books they are based off" morons would you truly laugh over this.
Wiki ***and learn something.
I'm laughing and dislike both the movies and the books.
he was busted for drugs or something a year or two back.
"***! Our chubby white actor is in jail, let's hire a skinny black replacement!" I'm all for racial equality and all, but that's just going too far lol.
Edit: Or a girl with brown eyes for the role of a character who is mentioned 90% of the time by the fact that Harry has her eyes.
He was already an actor on the previous film who was already a friend of Malfoys and can be read about in Half Blood Prince the book where he was a member of the slugclub with Harry, Hermoinie, and Ginny.
:-( You nuts are gonna get this thread scolded and locked if you don't stop posting qqs and start posting lolz. And then I will be forced to cry, whine, groan, and grumble. Please, think of the grumbles!
Due to the new forum rules, the old thread is being nuked. It's over 900 pages long, and there are numerous offending posts in it. And by numerous, I mean probably at LEAST one per page. Not including quotes.
Take the time to read through the below forum rules if you already have not. Remember, intentionally bypassing the profanity filter is not allowed.
Forum.Rules said:
We are implementing a global profanity filter for all users under 13, and for users not logged in. As we no longer ask for birthdays at registration, this means it will apply to all new users as well. (You can no longer verify your age, and the profanity filter option has not been added to account options yet.)
- Slurs based on race, ethnicity, sexual orientation, or similar protected statuses are not permitted, even in jest, or even by members of the same group.
- All sexual content now falls under "American network television" rules. While this naturally involves a certain gray area, if you won't see it on standard television (not cable), don't post it. (If you're not sure, don't post it.)
- Overly hostile and repeat attacks against a given user which would normally fall under harassment policies in-game will no longer be allowed.
- Posting any personal real-life identifiable information or images about a particular user without their permission is not allowed, unless they have previously posted it here.
- Player Warnings are no longer permitted. (This includes posting it in an already existing thread.)
- Do not link to or advertise external sites for blatant 3rd party hacks and tools that would probably get you immediately banned from FFXI/XIV. Guildwork Client and Windower are ok.
- These policies apply to all sections of the site: forum, item and player comments, screenshots, avatars, etc. Images violating any of the above rules will be removed if discovered by an admin or mod.
I will lock the other thread for now to give users time to save their favorites. It will be trashed this afternoon or tomorrow.
Edit: Do not expect a moderator to take the time to edit your post to remove a single image bypassing the profanity filter. If that is done, it is as a courtesy, not a requirement. If you are derailing or attacking someone, you risk your post being deleted regardless of including a picture in it.
Those that bypass the profanity filter risk being topicbanned. There is a profanity list. If you can't take the time to read it, then don't post images.